He Proposes. She Swears at Him. And Says “Yes”.
How did Joe propose to Rachel?
She knows it is coming — they had talked about it. But he had put her off — “I don’t have money for a ring.”
May 31, 2008. He plans to take her out to dinner. He tells her to dress up. She’s late, an hour late — as per usual. He’s panicking. He has a carriage ride set up on Michigan Ave. She has ridden horses her whole life — he wants to wow her.
They have a QUICK dinner at a different place than he first planned. They head towards Chicago. She is now suspicious.

They park by the Water Tower. As they approach the carriage, she sees roses and champagne. Then she KNOWS — and says to Joe, “Are you doing what I think you’re doing?”
He says, “Baby, I was going to do it but I FORGOT the ring because we were in such a rush. She believes him! She is mad. She looks like the world came crashing down. She says to him, “Don’t do it if you don’t have the ring. “Nothing ever works out for me.”
It’s a one hour carriage ride. 35 minutes go by. She’s still sad, not talking the whole time, giving him dirty looks. The carriage ride does a U-turn. She finally says something, “What are they doing?” He replies, “I don’t know.” “Probably just turning back,” she says.
The carriage ride stops in front of a garden. He gets out. “C’mon,” he says to her. “If you don’t have the ring, don’t do it,” she says again. She really thought he did NOT have it. He actually got FAKE tears to come down his cheeks.
They get under a gazebo. “You know, baby, I might not be perfect…” He gets down on one knee. She is even madder — she TOLD him not to. He pulls the ring out of his sock. “I love you more than anything.” Not until he holds the ring in front of her does she see it.
“Will you marry me?” She responds the way every guy hopes — she SWEARS at him! She is even madder! “Is that a yes?” THEN, she said “Yes” NOW, she thinks it’s funny.
The guests loved hearing me tell their story at Cantigny in Wheaton. Several people tell me later, “That sounds so much like Rachel.”
Cantigny is so beautiful that there were many other newly married couples getting their photo taken there — although their wedding and reception were elsewhere. Rachel and Joe had the ceremony, photos and reception all at one place.




